Creepy Cash — $2 New Mexico Scratcher #656
Creepy Cash (#656) is a $2 New Mexico scratcher launched on September 2, 2025. As of October 14, 2026 it ranks #9 of 47 active games on current payout (64.5%, $1.29 expected back per ticket) and #1 of 9 $2 games, #3 on any-prize odds (1 in 2.93) and #7 on top-prize odds (1 in 24,931). Since launch the payout has risen 4.6 points (59.9% at launch) and your chance of winning something has risen 29.9% (1 in 3.81 at launch). 1 of 20 top prizes of $500 remain, and we estimate 24,931 tickets are still unsold (89.9% sold). That is a middle-of-the-pack game: fine to play, but the ranking lists show better value at the same price. A caution on the current figures: the any-prize odds have moved from 1 in 3.81 to 1 in 2.93, further than a game's odds really move. Its prize tiers disagree about how many tickets are left (between 0.02 million and 0.04 million), usually because small prizes are claimed late, and the current odds and payout lean on that disagreement. The printed odds are the safer guide, and our summaries do not name this game the best of anything (how we estimate).
Prizes remaining
Every prize level in Creepy Cash, with the odds printed at launch, the odds today given what is left, and how much of each tier is still unclaimed. Across all tiers, 8,496 of 65,034 prizes (13.1%) are still out there.
| Prize | Odds at launch | Odds now | Total | Claimed | Remaining | % left |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $500 | 1 in 12,398 | 1 in 24,931 | 20 | 19 | 1 | 5.0% |
| $100 | 1 in 1,442 | 1 in 2,266 | 172 | 161 | 11 | 6.4% |
| $50 | 1 in 606.2 | 1 in 733.3 | 409 | 375 | 34 | 8.3% |
| $20 | 1 in 150.1 | 1 in 211.3 | 1,652 | 1,534 | 118 | 7.1% |
| $10 | 1 in 50.0 | 1 in 49.3 | 4,956 | 4,450 | 506 | 10.2% |
| $5 | 1 in 21.5 | 1 in 21.1 | 11,559 | 10,379 | 1,180 | 10.2% |
| $3 | 1 in 15.0 | 1 in 11.0 | 16,525 | 14,261 | 2,264 | 13.7% |
| $2 | 1 in 13.6 | 1 in 9.39 | 18,172 | 15,516 | 2,656 | 14.6% |
| FREE $2 TICKETfree ticket | 1 in 21.4 | 1 in 14.4 | 11,569 | 9,843 | 1,726 | 14.9% |
| All prizes | 1 in 3.81 | 1 in 2.93 | 65,034 | 56,538 | 8,496 | 13.1% |
How Creepy Cash has moved
Creepy Cash: common questions
- How many $500 prizes are left in Creepy Cash?
- 1 of 20 as of October 14, 2026. The chance that a ticket bought today is a top-prize winner is about 1 in 24,931.
- What are the odds of winning anything on Creepy Cash?
- 1 in 2.93 as of October 14, 2026, compared with 1 in 3.81 printed at launch. Cash-only odds are 1 in 3.46, and the odds of winning more than the $2 ticket price are 1 in 6.06.
- Is Creepy Cash worth buying?
- Its current payout is 64.5% ($1.29 back per $2 ticket), rank #9 of 47 in New Mexico. The best $2 alternative as of October 14, 2026 is Betty Boop™ (#670, $2) at 60.4%. No scratcher has a positive expected value; this is about losing less over time.
- How many Creepy Cash tickets are left?
- We estimate 24,931 of roughly 247,866 printed tickets are unsold (89.9% sold), derived from the prizes claimed at each tier and their published odds.
- When did Creepy Cash launch and is it still on sale?
- It launched on September 2, 2025. It is still on sale.
Other $2 New Mexico scratchers
- Betty Boop™ — 60.4% payout, 1 in 3.88 any prize
- Fast Cash — 59.4% payout, 1 in 3.85 any prize
- ELF — 58.9% payout, 1 in 3.98 any prize
- I Love Cash — 57.2% payout, 1 in 3.96 any prize
- $5,000 Grande — 56.8% payout, 1 in 4.12 any prize